Despite Open Cup wins, City stumbles in MLS

Boys in Blue fall to DC United after eliminating the Red Bulls

Former NYC shotstopper Sean Johnson kept a clean sheet for DC in Queens (Photo: Noah Zimmerman)

By Noah Zimmerman

noah@queensledger.com

CITI FIELD – It was another deflating outing in Queens for New York City FC on Sunday afternoon, now winless in their last seven league matches. While NYC’s flame was burning blue early in the season it has cooled since their defeat to Miami, seeing them drop from 1st to 9th in the East.

It hasn’t all been doom and gloom for New York. Outside of league play the club has enjoyed success in the Lamar Hunt US Open Cup, a competition in which NYC has often struggled. In their first four seasons of play the Boys in Blue were eliminated in their first cup match, twice to the NY Cosmos (formerly of the NASL) and twice to the rival Red Bulls.

The Red Bulls got their number once more in 2022, but this year City were able to flip the script, booking a trip to the quarterfinals for the 3rd time.

It was a trio of assists from Maxi Moralez that saw New York City vanquish their rivals on the road. The Argentinian delivered three great crosses for headed goals as NYC won 3-1 at Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, NJ.

Players, coaches, and fans hoped the big cup win would help reinvigorate the club as they returned to league play, but it wasn’t remotely the case. New York looked weak and ineffective on both ends of the pitch as DC United scored once in each half for a 2-0 win.

The NYC back line desperately misses Justin Haak. As the goals keep leaking it’s clear that it was a mistake to not prioritize retaining the homegrown defender. Partnered with Thiago Martins as a CB last year, Haak helped New York to one of the better defensive records in the league. This year they’ve already conceded 18 goals, tied for 13th worst in MLS.

The offense is also leaving plenty to be desired. The front office suggested they would pick out the right striker to hold the club over until Alonso Martinez returns from injury but no signing landed. Instead the club has relied on Nico Fernandez Mercau, who cooled off since starting the campaign on MVP pace, as well as a few youngsters still in need of development.

It didn’t help the New York offense that Sean Johnson was in great form. The former NYC man (and 2021 cup winner) made a number of phenomenal stops in goal for DC to help preserve a shutout.

The Boys in Blue need to get their play back up to MLS standards in order to remain viable in 2026, but their next stop in the Open Cup also looms later this month. On May 20 NYC will head to Ohio to play the Columbus Crew, with a win putting them into the cup semifinals for the first time in franchise history.

New York will also play Columbus in their next league match, hosting the Crew at Yankee Stadium on Mother’s Day. Between that match and their Open Cup rematch, the Boys in Blue will be on the road as they visit Charlotte on May 13 and the Red Bulls the following Saturday.

US Open Cup Brings Record-Setting Crowd to Westchester County’s Memorial Field

By Noah Zimmerman

noah@queensledger.com

It was a perfect night for a match at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, just a handful of minutes beyond the NYC border. For the first time ever, USL Division 1 club Westchester SC took on Major League Soccer’s New York City FC.

A crowd of 5,145 packed into Memorial Field, a humble stadium that seats 3,500 in the grandstand. For a club averaging 2,500 fans, it was a shot in the arm that could set up the club for tremendous growth this season and beyond. The club said the turnout marked a record attendance for a sports event in Westchester county.

It was a great atmosphere in Westchester as “traveling” NYC fans sang for all 90 minutes. Photos by Noah Zimmerman

“We would not have had a night like this without the US Open Cup. We recognize that NYCFC coming here is what drew this crowd, but for a club that’s just starting out that’s exactly what we needed,” said Ari Kwitkin-Close, Westchester SC’s chief revenue officer. “This was an opportunity to showcase our community club and who we are to this community and to the world.”

The crowd was buzzing and the “traveling” NYC fans kept their energy up in the away end from well before kickoff until almost an hour after the final whistle. The grandstand was packed with passionate fans and across the field food trucks and stands saw some of their longest lines ever.

“The atmosphere was great,” commented NYC manager Pascal Jansen postgame. “It was great for the fans to see their local club play against us. I hope they enjoyed themselves.”

On the pitch NYC showed their class as a top-division team. They were in steady control for most of the match, opening the scoring through Augstin Ojeda in the 14th minute. Westchester were up to the task as they found an equalizer less than 10 minutes later. Daniel Burko lashed in a loose ball to even the score at 1-1, sending the local fans into a frenzy.

A few minutes later, a tough penalty decision from the referee gave the visitors a foothold. Talles Magno scored the first of his three goals from the penalty spot in the 25th minute and increased the lead to 3-1 in the 36th. Spanish youngster Arnau Farnós put a fourth goal into the net before halftime, and Magno finished his hat trick in the 71st minute, their lone second half goal.

Westchester pulled one more goal back through Brecc Evans, but didn’t have time for more as it finished 5-2. Still, it was a valiant effort, and a better one than some MLS clubs have gotten against New York this season (NYC defeated Orlando 5-0 in March).

Tayvon Gray got the captain’s armband for the Open Cup battle.

After falling in the Open Cup, focus turns back to the USL League 1 season and upcoming USL Cup for Westchester. They sit in the league’s top-7 after six matches played, rapidly climbing with wins over Corpus Christi and Sarasota.

“Now the biggest thing is continuing this momentum with the crowd to support our guys on the field,” said Kwitkin-Close. “League play we’re on a heater so we have to keep that going.”

 

Disappointment in Flushing

Following Tuesday’s victory in Westchester, the Boys in Blue returned to Queens for a weekend contest against Charlotte FC. In their return to league play, the NYC offense looked toothless and tame despite decent buildup play.

Even with 22 total shots (7 on goal) and 42 touches inside Charlotte’s penalty area, New York only registered three significant chances. Coming to the rescue multiple times was Kristijan Kahlina, making six saves in the winning effort.

NYC will look to bounce back from three defeats in their last four league matches (the fourth being a 1-1 draw) with a midweek match vs Cincinnati at Yankee Stadium and a Saturday clash in Montreal. They continue their Open Cup run against the rival Red Bulls next Wednesday.

Fill the Form for Events, Advertisement or Business Listing